Find Local Events (pick a date)
 
Browse Boulder real estate by neighborhood, school and zip code along with other homes for sale in Colorado on COhomefinder.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Home / Articles / Entertainment / Books /  Natural-born talent? Author sheds new light on nature-nurture debate
. . . . . . .
Give Through iGivefirst
Thursday, April 22,2010

Natural-born talent? Author sheds new light on nature-nurture debate

By Adam Perry

Like most Americans, I was given an IQ test in the first grade and was told I fell just short of what my teachers and parents called “gifted.” Several times a week from elementary school through high school, the students labeled “gifted” were separated from the rest of us to be given extra attention, extra praise, more diverse and interesting schoolwork, and even a better teacher.

To the adults I met as a child, a person’s capacity for achievement could be decided at around age 6 or 7 by a simple equation: genes environment, or “nature nurture.” Given an extra dose of more expansive learning by dynamic teachers, they thought, a “gifted” child could metaphorically grow from a caterpillar into a butterfly. But they were convinced that the rest of us are eternally mired in the sad-but-true stasis known as being average, wholly incapable of growing wings no matter the effort or interest.

Here’s a shocker: Some students labeled “gifted” go on to impressive success and some do not, just like the rest of us. So how does a childhood overachiever, constantly heaped with praise, end up dropping out of college and working in a fast-food joint? How does a troubled high school dropout who never stepped foot in a university become a renowned artist and intellectual whose lectures are treasured worldwide?

David Shenk, author of the best-selling new book The Genius in All of Us, has the answer, and it’s a simple one: nature multiplied by nurture.

“No one is genetically bound to mediocrity,” Shenk writes. In fact, even Alfred Binet (inventor of the original IQ test) insisted that we “protest” against the idea that “intelligence is a fixed quantity.” Instead, our genes interact with our environment, and the success of our scholarly, creative and professional evolution is directly related to the cultural exposure we’re afforded and the demands put on us by our environment and ourselves.

“It’s pretty easy in life to take a mediocre path,” Shenk told Boulder Weekly in a recent interview. “Bad parenting can get us there pretty quickly. So can lousy schools and/ or a limited sense of one’s own potential. But the possibilities of achievement are never fully cut off. We remain adaptable throughout our lives.”

Robert C. Brown, who founded the contemplative education department at Naropa University in 1990, agrees.

“The learning environment is a key element in developing intelligence in the broadest sense of the word,” Brown says. “It’s a matter of expanding our learning relationships. What we mean by intelligence or genius has been widened in recent times … but we don’t know how to recognize it, and usually our teachers don’t. Part of the reason for that is that we haven’t learned how to actually observe or contemplate individual genius. … If we [don’t] recognize it, we don’t really know how to cultivate it.”

In a 1958 lab study documented in The Genius in All of Us, psychologists at the University of Manitoba raised two genetic strains of rats (labeled “dull” and “bright”) in three distinct environments — “enriched,” “normal” and “restricted” (or devoid of stimulation). Expecting to prove that, as Shenk wrote, “each strain would get a little smarter in the enriched environment and a little dumber in the restricted environment,” the results turned out to be astonishing.

The “dull” and “bright” rats — genetically consistent over many generations — lived up to their genetic brands under “normal” conditions but performed almost exactly the same as each other when raised in an environment rich with stimulation or condemned to a boredom-filled upbringing.

Not surprisingly, the game-changing revelation that Shenk calls “the geneenvironment interactive dynamic” applies to humans as well. A child labeled “average” and simultaneously confined to cultural isolation in a place where edifying books, art, teachers and experiences are all but foreign can easily fade into the indistinguishable masses of unremarkable individuals. But, given the same chance as those we label “gifted” — and a whole lot of what Shenk describes as “deliberate practice” (at least 10,000 hours of focused, singular activity in which our previous limits are painfully stretched) — almost anyone can flourish.

The work has to start early and almost never cease. Think of people like Mozart and baseball legend Ted Williams — accomplished heroes we regularly portray as having “God-given talent.” With Williams, Mozart, Michael Jordan and Yo-Yo Ma as examples, Shenk asserts that what we call “talent” does not exist. Instead, deliberate practice (the crux of Shenk’s idea of how to cultivate genius) functions in tandem with motivation and stimulation (plus the genes we’re given) to create magnificence in everything from mathematics to basketball.

In short, with the exception of aberrations such as autism, geniuses are “trained,” not born.

Still, none of this new information suggests that schools should stop giving IQ tests to children. However, perhaps we should stop telling children that their IQ circa grade school represents their promise in life, or even their prospective IQ.

“Humans are not assigned, by genetic code or by IQ test performance, to achievement levels — learning is a matter of participating within social and cultural systems, not bubbling in the correct circle on a test,” says University of Colorado professor Noah Finkelstein, a leading researcher in studies of student learning in physics and science.

Finkelstein lamented that “our society builds expectations into the way we test and sort students,” adding that “these expectations do not match nor reflect the potential capacities of our students.”

Shenk concurs. “I don’t think we have to replace the test itself,” he says. “The test works fine. It’s how we talk about the test that’s the problem. We need to make sure that parents and kids understand that tests reflect current abilities — they do not reveal one’s inner potential.”

That goes for those labeled “gifted” early on, too.

“Childhood achievers are frequently hobbled by the psychology of their own success,” Shenk writes in a chapter about prodigies who unravel after childhoods spent in the bosom of “praise for being technically proficient at a specific task.” Prodigies often “develop natural aversion to stepping outside their comfort zone,” manifesting the “terrible fear of new challenges and of any sort of flaw or failure.” Thus, post-childhood success can be thwarted, partly due to impenetrable social walls constructed in seclusion amid the effort to sustain acclaim from adults who recognize them only as a “whiz kid.”

Getting back to that “promising beginning” can be excruciating.

“It certainly can be difficult for a once-prodigy to find his or her way in adulthood,” Shenk says, “and that includes maintaining a passion for one’s craft. Part of it involves a new understanding of achievement as a collection of skills, rather than innate giftedness.”

Shenk’s diversely impressive career trajectory — which has seen him shift from co-authoring a cult-classic on the Grateful Dead to lecturing on information technology and penning a hugely successful book on Alzheimer’s that became a PBS film — also reveals a writer and thinker always eager to remain both iconoclastic and interested. Surely our educational systems could encourage this kind of far-reaching scholarship from kindergarten on.

Says Naropa’s Brown, “When we are educating for only a narrow band-width of intelligence, it becomes very fragile and unsustainable. When we start thinking very broadly about the meaning of education, then individual excellence starts to manifest.”

It’s obviously harmful in many ways for children who are praised for proficiency in one area to be withheld from meaningful opportunities to grow in what Finkelstein calls “a rich mixture of individual and environment.” But how fortunate that each of us has the chance to survive suffocating social and cultural structures and become a whiz kid at any age.

Respond: letters@boulderweekly.com

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
POST A COMMENT
No Registration Required
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

The company currently employs 1,124 people and has more than doubled its staff since 2010, when it employed 525, the article reports.carding 

 

I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things. Fifa 15 Hack

 

The Genius in All of Us, has the answer, and it’s a simple one: nature multiplied by nurture.good payday loans

 

Post a specimen application to cloudfoundry and offer the connection, that way we're all having a striking resemblance thing. garcinia cambogia review

 

Bad parenting can get us there pretty quickly. So can lousy schools and/ or a limited sense of one’s own potential. bubblegum casting

 

You completed several fine points there. I did a search on the subject and found the majority of persons will go along with with your blog. turkey photographers

 

We have to care for rich measure in our bankroll with the proposition that we can play again and again. online long term loans no credit check

 

Thanks for a nice share you have given to us with such an large collection of information. Great work you have done by sharing them to all. simply superb. girlsdoporn

 

How does a troubled high school dropout who never stepped foot in a university become a renowned artist and intellectual whose lectures are treasured worldwid girlsdoporn

 

The enriched environment and a little dumber in the restricted environment,” the results turned out to be astonishing.bosphorus cruise

 

Directly related to the cultural exposure we’re afforded and the demands put on us by our environment and ourselves.bubblegum casting

 

What we mean by intelligence or genius has been widened in recent times … but we don’t know how to recognize it, and usually our teachers don’t. girlsdoporn

 

Other when raised in an environment rich with stimulation or condemned to a boredom-filled upbringing.bubblegum casting

 

I am not sure from where you’re getting your information, but really good topic chosen by you. I need to spend some time for learning or understanding more. hack fb account

 

they were convinced that the rest of us are eternally mired in the sad-but-true stasis known as being average, wholly incapable of growing wings no matter the effort or interest. Finding Dough As It's Needed Rapidly

 

This data gave by you is extremely down to earth for good arranging. http://plomberiedasilva.fr

 

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us. https://archive.org/details/girlfriend-activation-system-review/

 

Being a soccer mom is equivalent to having a part-time job with a demanding schedule. My top ten soccer mom ideas will hopefully assist balance in your life and at the same time help improve your son or daughter's soccer skills. www.scorespro.com

 

I like this idea. I went by your online journal shockingly and turned into your fan. depannage serrurier 24h24

 

This was the primary spot that let me know the answer.well I earnestly loved contemplating it. free cell phone with medicaid

 

This data gave by you is extremely handy for good arranging.It's elusive quality written work like yours nowadays. carbonfiberco

 

Your post is a fantastic illustration of why I hold returning to peruse your great quality substance. I'm truly inspired with the substance you gave. astuce clash of clans

 

I am eager to see a printing business as yet working and developing, awesome employment gentlemen. teds woodworking plans review

 

They must make a decent outline for the leaflet. So viewers can be intrigued for nearing. parachute pants for women

 

Bad parenting can get us there pretty quickly. So can lousy schools and/ or a limited sense of one’s own potential.girlsdoporn

 

Your online journal truly brought a few things to light that I never would have thought about previously understanding it You made an incredible showing here. My site here

 

I am looking forward for the following profitable and instructive idea in your site. Painter and Decorator Edinburgh

 

It is exceptionally delight to get it as I got enormous helps right here. I exceedingly admire the bloggers workings and will hold up for more post from the administrator. various signs of cocaine dependence

 

If possible, as you gain information, please update this blog with more information. I have found it really useful.read more

 

Thankfulness star offering. I like it. I certainly favored concerning every minimal next to no of it. http://www.areesecelticastrology.com/gemini-monthly-zodiac-2015/

 

I could perceive how full this site with society. I think you made some great focuses in Features too. Continue working, incredible occupation! read the article

 

I believe that at some point later on I may attempt to compose a book to oblige my site, however we will see.Good post with valuable tips and thoughts. software for making music

 

Great new interface and pleasant useful articles. I will be returning soon, a debt of gratitude is in order regarding the immense article. plombier orly

 

I am abundantly awed by the choice furthermore it is important to proclaim if there is no change has been come. microsoftoffice2010.co

 

this will help me such a great amount in my learning. It is extraordinary to have the chance to peruse a decent quality article with helpful data on themes that bounty are intrigued on. paid social media jobs reviews

 

I will remember it, a debt of gratitude is in order regarding imparting the data, looking forward for more posts. desatascos en tres cantos

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

Great post! keep up the good work and also never forget that we have bosphorus cruise

 

I touch truly exact form these articles I closefisted there are journalists that can make good stuff. Student Caring

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

It's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.http://youtu.be/vpONEF9ORkI

 

So luck to come across your excellent blog. Your blog brings me a great deal of fun.. Good luck with the site. jesus christ

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

 

 

%u05D1%u05E8%u05D5%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9%u05EA %u05DE%u05D3%u05D4%u05D9%u05DE%u05D4 %u05E8%u05E7 %u05DC%u05E8%u05D1%u05D5%u05EA VIP! %u05D1%u05D7%u05D5%u05E8%u05D4 %u05D9%u05E4%u05D4 %u05E2%u05DD %u05D0%u05D3%u05DD %u05D4%u05D2%u05D5%u05DF %u05D7%u05D2  %u05D3%u05DE%u05D5%u05EA %u05D0%u05DC%u05D2%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9%u05EA.

 %u05DE%u05D5%u05D0%u05E8, %u05DE%u05DC%u05D0 %u05EA%u05E9%u05D5%u05E7%u05D4, %u05DE%u05E1%u05EA%u05D5%u05E8%u05D9

, %u05D0%u05DC%u05D2%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9, %u05DE%u05EA%u05D7%u05E9%u05D1 %u05D5%u05E1%u05E7%u05E1%u05D9, %u05D2%u05D1%u05E8%u05EA %u05D0%u05DE%u05D9%u05EA%u05D9%u05EA

 %u05E2%u05DD %u05E0%u05D9%u05DE%u05D5%u05E1%u05D9%u05DD %u05D8%u05D5%u05D1%u05D9%u05DD %u05D5%u05D8%u05E2%u05DD %u05DE%u05E9%u05D5%u05D1%u05D7 %u05DE%u05D7%u05DB%u05D4 %u05DC %u05DC%u05D1%u05E7%u05E8. %u05D1%u05E0%u05E4%u05E8%u05D3. %u05DE%u05DB%u05E8%u05D4 100% %u05EA%u05DE%u05D5%u05E0%u05D4. %u05E7%u05D5%u05E8%u05D0 %u05DC%u05EA%u05E9%u05D5%u05D1%u05D4 %u05E2%u05E6%u05DE%u05D5.%u05D4%u05D3%u05D9%u05E8%u05D4 %u05DE%u05D5%u05D2%u05E0%u05EA

 %u05D0%u05DD %u05DC%u05D0 %u05D4%u05E8%u05D9%u05DD %u05D0%u05EA %u05D4%u05D8%u05DC%u05E4%u05D5%u05DF, %u05DC%u05D4%u05EA%u05E7%u05E9%u05E8 %u05E9%u05D5%u05D1:-) 1000 %u05E7%u05DC%u05D0%u05E1%u05D9 %u05E9%u05E2%u05D4, %u05E6%u05D5%u05E2%u05E7 %u05D5%u05E2%u05D9%u05E1%u05D5%u05D9 %u05D0%u05E8%u05D5%u05D8%u05D9

 

http://escort-center.info/

http://escort-center.com/

http://0544342878.com


 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT

 

%u05D1%u05E8%u05D5%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9%u05EA %u05DE%u05D3%u05D4%u05D9%u05DE%u05D4 %u05E8%u05E7 %u05DC%u05E8%u05D1%u05D5%u05EA VIP! %u05D1%u05D7%u05D5%u05E8%u05D4 %u05D9%u05E4%u05D4 %u05E2%u05DD %u05D0%u05D3%u05DD %u05D4%u05D2%u05D5%u05DF %u05D7%u05D2  %u05D3%u05DE%u05D5%u05EA %u05D0%u05DC%u05D2%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9%u05EA.

 %u05DE%u05D5%u05D0%u05E8, %u05DE%u05DC%u05D0 %u05EA%u05E9%u05D5%u05E7%u05D4, %u05DE%u05E1%u05EA%u05D5%u05E8%u05D9

, %u05D0%u05DC%u05D2%u05E0%u05D8%u05D9, %u05DE%u05EA%u05D7%u05E9%u05D1 %u05D5%u05E1%u05E7%u05E1%u05D9, %u05D2%u05D1%u05E8%u05EA %u05D0%u05DE%u05D9%u05EA%u05D9%u05EA

 %u05E2%u05DD %u05E0%u05D9%u05DE%u05D5%u05E1%u05D9%u05DD %u05D8%u05D5%u05D1%u05D9%u05DD %u05D5%u05D8%u05E2%u05DD %u05DE%u05E9%u05D5%u05D1%u05D7 %u05DE%u05D7%u05DB%u05D4 %u05DC %u05DC%u05D1%u05E7%u05E8. %u05D1%u05E0%u05E4%u05E8%u05D3. %u05DE%u05DB%u05E8%u05D4 100% %u05EA%u05DE%u05D5%u05E0%u05D4. %u05E7%u05D5%u05E8%u05D0 %u05DC%u05EA%u05E9%u05D5%u05D1%u05D4 %u05E2%u05E6%u05DE%u05D5.%u05D4%u05D3%u05D9%u05E8%u05D4 %u05DE%u05D5%u05D2%u05E0%u05EA

 %u05D0%u05DD %u05DC%u05D0 %u05D4%u05E8%u05D9%u05DD %u05D0%u05EA %u05D4%u05D8%u05DC%u05E4%u05D5%u05DF, %u05DC%u05D4%u05EA%u05E7%u05E9%u05E8 %u05E9%u05D5%u05D1:-) 1000 %u05E7%u05DC%u05D0%u05E1%u05D9 %u05E9%u05E2%u05D4, %u05E6%u05D5%u05E2%u05E7 %u05D5%u05E2%u05D9%u05E1%u05D5%u05D9 %u05D0%u05E8%u05D5%u05D8%u05D9

 

http://escort-center.info/

http://escort-center.com/

http://0544342878.com

 

 
Close
Close